WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation compared with axe DevTools and Pa11y| WAVE (WebAIM) | axe DevTools (Deque) | Pa11y |
|---|
| Delivery and platform: WAVE is a suite from WebAIM and Utah State University: an online service where you enter a URL, plus extensions for Chrome, Firefox and Edge. The extensions suit password-protected, local or highly dynamic pages. | Delivery and platform: The free extension runs inside the developer tools of Chrome, and separate free extensions exist for Edge and Firefox. It is aimed at individual developers and testers. | Delivery and platform: Pa11y runs from the command line or from Node.js. Version 10 requires an even-numbered Node.js release, 22.13.0 or later. |
| Rule engine and standards: It identifies many accessibility and WCAG errors and concentrates on issues that affect end users. | Rule engine and standards: It builds on the axe-core rules library. The page does not list the WCAG versions or criteria covered by the extension. | Rule engine and standards: The default runner is HTML_CodeSniffer, and the axe runner can be selected or combined with it. Standards are WCAG2A, WCAG2AA (default) and WCAG2AAA, the last one only with the HTML_CodeSniffer runner. |
| Licence and cost model: The online tool and extensions are offered by WebAIM. A subscription API is offered for collecting test data across many pages. | Licence and cost model: The extension is free. The Pro version, with a free trial, adds Intelligent Guided Tests, saving, exporting and sharing results, and testing of individual components. | Licence and cost model: Pa11y is open source under LGPL-3.0-only. |
| Automation and CI: A stand-alone API and testing engine can run on intranet, non-public or secure pages and be built into continuous integration processes. | | Automation and CI: Exit code 0 means no errors, 1 a technical fault and 2 errors on the page. Reporters include cli, csv, html, json and tsv, and scripted actions such as clicking or filling a field can run before the test. |
| Manual testing and limits: The AIM report includes expert manual test results and a site-level score based on end-user impact, so human evaluation is part of the offer. | Manual testing and limits: Deque states that the extension helps catch 57 percent of accessibility issues while coding, without a stated method. Intelligent Guided Tests ask questions about the page to build an issue report. | |