REBA Assessment Tool compared with Siemens Tecnomatix Jack and CATIA Human Builder| REBA Assessment Tool (ErgoPlus) | Siemens Tecnomatix Jack | CATIA Human Builder |
|---|
| Type of tool: A guided scoring tool for the Rapid Entire Body Assessment method, offered by ErgoPlus, a Briotix Health solution. You enter observed postures and the tool combines region scores into one risk score. | Type of tool: A 3D digital human modelling package for process and workstation simulation. Manikins are sized from anthropometric databases of regions around the world and placed in a virtual workplace. | Type of tool: A digital manikin module in the CATIA V5 product line (Human Builder and Simulation). Workbenches cover Human Builder, Human Measurements Editor, Human Posture Analysis and Human Activity Analysis. |
| Ergonomic methods covered: REBA, the whole-body method that scores posture, forceful exertion, type of movement, repetition and coupling. ErgoPlus also publishes RULA, NIOSH Lifting Equation, WISHA and Snook Tables as separate tools. | Ergonomic methods covered: The fact sheet names NIOSH, OWAS and RULA assessments, plus fatigue, low back injury risk, energy expenditure and strength prediction. REBA is not named in Siemens material for Jack. | Ergonomic methods covered: The product page describes posture, comfort and vision analysis. It does not name RULA, REBA or any other scoring method. |
| Source of posture data: Manual input by the evaluator, who scores posture, force, movement, repetition and coupling per body region on the form. | Source of posture data: Postures come from simulated manikins that can be positioned, driven by task simulation, or fed from motion tracking and virtual reality systems. Postures are recalculated when objects or weights change. | Source of posture data: Postures come from manikins manipulated in a virtual product model. The page mentions varied population and anthropometry data as the basis for manikin creation. |
| Scale and effort: Assessment of a single observed task, producing individual region scores that are combined through tables into one risk score. | Scale and effort: Ergonomic studies can be linked directly to the manufacturing process structure in an integrated PLM environment. In a Siemens demonstration, Teamcenter managed the process data. | Scale and effort: Manikins interact with virtual products, and the workbenches include DMU Space Analysis. V5 Human catalogs store company ergonomics know-how. |
| Access and cost model: ErgoPlus describes its assessment tools as free and offers free step-by-step guides. A separate ErgoPlus software platform is presented through demos and a product tour. | Access and cost model: Siemens software. A 30-day free trial was announced in December 2013. A 2014 Siemens post uses the name Process Simulate Human for the human simulation. | Access and cost model: Part of the CATIA V5 product line, listed under PLM Express. It is shown as separate from DELMIA Ergonomics. |