Electricity Maps compared with ENTSO-E Transparency Platform, WattTime and Grid Status| Electricity Maps | ENTSO-E Transparency Platform | WattTime | Grid Status |
|---|
| Quantity provided: Carbon intensity of consumed electricity for each zone, calculated with a flow-tracing method that accounts for imports and exports between grids. | Quantity provided: Market and system data published by European operators: load, generation, transmission, balancing, outages, congestion management and system operations. It is a data publication, not a carbon accounting product. | Quantity provided: The marginal CO2 signal (MOER), which is the emissions rate of the generators that respond when demand changes. It covers operating combustion CO2 only, not upstream or lifecycle emissions. | Quantity provided: Electricity supply, demand and price data such as fuel mix, load, forecasts and locational marginal prices from North American grid operators. Emissions factors are not the focus. |
| Geographic coverage: Over 200 zones, with data drawn from more than 100 sources. | Geographic coverage: Pan-European, based on EU Transparency Regulation 543/2013 and maintained by ENTSO-E. | Geographic coverage: Global, with more than 200 countries and territories, usually split into balancing regions or subregions. | Geographic coverage: U.S. and Canadian grid operators (for example CAISO, ERCOT, PJM, MISO, NYISO, ISONE, SPP, IESO, AESO), plus the EIA in the open source library. |
| Time resolution and horizon: History from 2017, real time data and 72 hour forecasts. | | Time resolution and horizon: Five minute granularity, history of at least two years, and a rolling 72 hour forecast. | Time resolution and horizon: Historical and real time data through a hosted API with more than 500 datasets, including load forecasts. |
| Method and processing: Peer reviewed flow-tracing methodology, described by the provider as open source with a community of contributors. | | Method and processing: Empirical model based on a technique from peer reviewed literature, validated by the provider research team. Imports, exports and renewable curtailment are estimated. | Method and processing: The open source Python library returns minimally processed operator data. The hosted API is recommended by the project for production use. |
| Access and licence: A REST API with a free tier that developers can use for applications outside their commercial workplace. Commercial use requires a paid arrangement. | Access and licence: Data is publicly available. An open RESTful API suits limited volumes near real time, while bulk downloads through the web interface require registration and login. | Access and licence: Access is through an API with separate data plans. Plan terms were not stated on the signal description page. | Access and licence: The library is released under the BSD-3-Clause licence. The hosted API needs an API key and its free tier is limited to 500,000 rows per month. |