Beam Deflection Calculator compared with RISA, SkyCiv and Roark formulas| Beam Deflection Calculator | RISA | SkyCiv | Roark formulas |
|---|
| Scope and method: Closed-form maximum deflection of simply supported and cantilever beams under simple load cases: midspan or offset point load, uniform, uniformly varying and triangular load, and an end moment. Combined loads are handled by superposition, which is only approximate. | Scope and method: RISA-3D is a finite element program with static, dynamic, time history, eigenvalue and response spectra analysis, P-Delta effects and automated mesh refinement. It goes far beyond single-beam formulas. | Scope and method: SkyCiv Beam models beams of any complexity with supports, load layouts and load combinations. It returns reactions, shear forces, bending moments, deflection and stresses. | Scope and method: A printed reference with more than 5,000 formulas covering more than 1,500 load and support conditions, arranged as tables by chapter, case and subcase. It also treats columns, plates, shells, torsion, contact stress and fatigue. |
| Inputs and outputs: Inputs are span, load, modulus of elasticity and area moment of inertia (or flexural rigidity). The only output is the maximum deflection, taken about the x-axis for vertical loads. | | Inputs and outputs: Beam sections can come from a library of over 20,000 standard profiles, from built-up sections or from DXF import. Output includes PDF reports and 3D deflection animations. | Inputs and outputs: The user reads the formula for the matching case and evaluates it by hand or in a spreadsheet. Each case has a diagram. |
| Design code checks: None. The result is a deflection value that the engineer compares with a limit. | Design code checks: Design features cover steel, concrete, masonry, wood and aluminum, plus seismic design and cold-formed steel wall design. The site mentions ASCE 7-22 and AISC 360-22 support. | Design code checks: Integrated steel, timber, cold-formed and concrete beam design checks, with step-by-step working and a section optimizer. | |
| Cost model and access: Runs on a web page. Each page shows the formulas next to the result, so the calculation can be verified by hand. | Cost model and access: Priced annually, with a free 10-day trial, direct purchase, cloud licensing and educational licences. | Cost model and access: Cloud based and used in any browser without installation. A free beam calculator and a free sign-up exist, with flexible plans and no lock-in contracts. | Cost model and access: Published by McGraw Hill as a book. The ninth edition appeared in March 2020, and the first edition dates from 1938. |
| Integration: Works with Autodesk Revit, Tekla Structures, Archicad and SDS2, and with RISAFloor, RISAFoundation and RISAConnection in the RISA Building Suite. | Integration: Links to SkyCiv Section Builder and to an API, whose details are not given on the feature page. | |