Pressure Drop Online Calculator compared with Pipe-Flo, Crane TP-410 and AFT Fathom| Pressure Drop Online Calculator | Pipe-Flo | Crane TP-410 | AFT Fathom |
|---|
| Scope: Computes the pressure drop of liquids and gases in single pipes and pipe elements, in laminar and turbulent flow. Element groups include straight pipes, bends, valves, nozzles and orifices, and strainers. | Scope: Software for designing, analyzing and troubleshooting fluid piping systems, with pump and valve sizing and selection wizards. Unlike the online calculator, it works on a whole piping system drawn in a graphical Flo-Sheet. | Scope: A reference publication on the flow of fluid through valves, pipes and fittings. The 2009 edition adds chapters on pumps, control valves and flow meters. | Scope: Calculates pressure drop and flow distribution in liquid and low-velocity gas piping and ducting. It also models centrifugal and positive displacement pumps, including NPSH and pump-versus-system curves. |
| Inputs: Element type, pipe diameter and length, roughness (with a roughness database), flow rate, density and viscosity, each in several units. Gases also need inlet absolute pressure and the inlet and outlet temperatures. | Inputs: Fluid properties can be entered freely and calculated with the DIPPR, polynomial or Yaws formulae. | Inputs: The user applies the published resistance values and calculation methods by hand. Resistance coefficients are based on tests at the Crane Engineering Laboratories. | Inputs: A built-in fluid and fitting library that can be extended. The optional Chempak add-on provides a database of almost 700 fluids. |
| Fluid coverage: Liquids and gases, selected through a condition field. | | | Fluid coverage: Water, petroleum products, chemicals, cryogens, refrigerants and low-velocity gases. Both Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids are supported, and an add-on handles settling slurries. |
| Cost model and access: Used in the web page without an account, but a CAPTCHA must be solved before calculating. The page links to a newer version at pressure-drop.online. | | Cost model and access: Sold as a publication through the Flow of Fluids store. It is cited by AHRI 551/591:2015 according to the Building CodeHub. | Cost model and access: Commercial licence that includes one year of technical support. Modules such as Extended Time Simulation, Goal Seek and Control, and Settling Slurry are optional add-ons. |
| Integration and extensions: Flo-Links connect the Flo-Sheet to external websites or Windows applications, according to a trade article from 2001. | | Integration and extensions: Imports GIS shapefiles, CAESAR II Neutral files and component files from AutoCAD Plant 3D, SmartPlant and CADWorx. It also exchanges data with EPANET and Excel, and uses a Newton-Raphson hydraulic solver. |