PhET Interactive Simulations compared with Wolfram Demonstrations and Labster| PhET Interactive Simulations | Wolfram Demonstrations | Labster |
|---|
| Subject coverage: Physics, math and statistics, chemistry, earth and space, and biology. Typical topics are buoyancy, gravity and pH. The emphasis is on concepts that a first-year student must visualise. | Subject coverage: Science, mathematics, engineering, technology, business, art, finance and social sciences, with thousands of free applications. The range is wider and often more technical or specialised than PhET. | Subject coverage: Simulated virtual labs for higher-education STEM in biology, chemistry, physics and health sciences, with more than 300 simulations. It also offers UbiSim, a separate VR product for nursing. |
| Pedagogical design: Each simulation is tested and evaluated through student interviews and classroom observation. The design follows research on how students learn. | Pedagogical design: Applications are contributed as individual demonstrations of a concept. A page for each one does not describe a pedagogical evaluation. | Pedagogical design: Course-oriented: automated grading, quiz customisation, unlimited attempts and assignment from within a learning management system. |
| Openness and platform: All simulations are open source. They run online, can be downloaded for offline use, and iOS and Android apps are available. The language menu lists about 47 options. | Openness and platform: Runs in a JavaScript-enabled browser. The page does not state whether the code is open. | Openness and platform: A hosted commercial platform sold to institutions. It integrates with learning management systems and with bookstore services for purchase. |
| Cost: Free. Sponsors support the project so students and teachers pay nothing. | Cost: The applications are described as free. | Cost: Quote-based pricing that depends on program size. No prices are published. |
| When to choose it: Choose it for free, tested, downloadable visual demonstrations in class or for self-study, including offline. | When to choose it: Choose it to explore a specific mathematical or engineering model beyond the standard curriculum. | When to choose it: Choose it when an institution needs graded lab-style activities that replace or prepare hands-on laboratory work. |