LOOPY Systems Thinking Tool compared with Vensim, Stella and Insight Maker| LOOPY Systems Thinking Tool | Vensim | Stella | Insight Maker |
|---|
| Modelling approach: LOOPY lets you draw nodes and arrows for causal relationships and then run the simulation to watch reinforcing and balancing loops. You can change a value and see it spread through the system, which suits qualitative exploration. | Modelling approach: Vensim PLE is described as fully functional system dynamics software. It is the entry edition, and Vensim PLE Plus, Professional and DSS exist for simulation and analysis features that PLE lacks. | Modelling approach: Stella Architect combines system dynamics, discrete events and some agent-based modelling in one model. Assemblies provide premade model structures that give a running model quickly. | Modelling approach: Insight Maker supports causal loop diagrams and stock and flow models, with Euler and fourth-order Runge-Kutta integration. It also supports agent-based modelling with states, transitions, and spatial and network relationships. |
| Licence and cost: LOOPY is open source and public domain, with the source code on GitHub. It is free to reuse and remix for coders, educators and others. | Licence and cost: PLE is free for academic and personal use. For commercial use it can be evaluated for 90 days, after which a commercial licence must be bought. | Licence and cost: Stella Architect is sold as a non-academic licence or as subscriptions of several lengths, with education discounts, and a 30-day evaluation licence exists. Stella Online, the isee Player and the Stella in Excel add-in are free. | Licence and cost: Insight Maker is a free, browser-based tool. It lists itself as free and open source and links to an open-source JavaScript simulation library on GitHub, though the licence is not named on the features page. |
| Analysis and validation features: The tool is built for interaction and learning, not for numerical analysis. Its value is making feedback effects visible that are hard to see in a static diagram. | Analysis and validation features: PLE has simplified menus and dialogs, a fixed tool set, fewer model-building tools and fewer functions than the paid editions. | Analysis and validation features: It checks equations and units, and offers sensitivity analysis, Loops That Matter and Causal Lens for tracing feedback loops. A Vensim Translator imports Vensim models. | Analysis and validation features: Model Scripting, macros and functions are available, and equations support imperative, functional and object-oriented programming. |
| Sharing and publication: Models are remixed from other people simulations. The LOOPY page itself offers share buttons, but it does not describe how individual models are saved. | | Sharing and publication: Interfaces can be published to the web, desktop or mobile devices, and users need only a modern browser. Publishing for Excel lets people run models in Microsoft Excel through the free Stella in Excel add-in. | Sharing and publication: A model can be shared by link, embedded in a website or blog, and edited jointly. Insights can be set to private or public. |