Internet Archive: WayBack Machine compared with Perma.cc and Webrecorder| Internet Archive: WayBack Machine | Perma.cc | Webrecorder |
|---|
| Purpose and scope: A public archive of the web that lets you enter a URL, pick a date and browse earlier versions of a page. Its Save Page Now function also captures a page as it appears at that moment, so it can be cited later. | Purpose and scope: A service from the Harvard Library Innovation Lab that turns a cited URL into a permanent link. The reader reaches a page offering both the original source and the archived copy, with the creation date. | Purpose and scope: A set of tools rather than one service: ArchiveWeb.page records pages while you browse, ReplayWeb.page plays archives back, and Browsertrix crawls whole sites automatically. |
| Capture method and limits: Captures come from web crawls. Standard HTML archives well, but pages relying on forms, JavaScript or live interaction lose that functionality. Password-protected pages are excluded, and robots exclusions or owner requests can block a site. | Capture method and limits: The user submits a URL and Perma.cc downloads the content. | Capture method and limits: Browsertrix crawls in real browsers, so JavaScript-loaded content can be captured, and browser profiles give access to logged-in pages without exposing a password. Crawls can be scheduled and compared with the live site. |
| Formats and programmatic access: Stored files include WARC. A Wayback availability JSON API returns the closest snapshot to a date, and a CDX server API supports filtering and analysis of capture data. | Formats and programmatic access: Archives can be downloaded as WARC or WACZ files through a REST API at api.perma.cc/v1. Most endpoints need an API key, and ReplayWeb.page is recommended for viewing them. | Formats and programmatic access: Archives are exported as WACZ, which can be unzipped to obtain the WARC files. Browsertrix signs WACZ outputs digitally and deduplicates content across crawls. |
| Openness and licence: The Perma code is public on GitHub under a dual MIT and GPL version 3 licence. | Openness and licence: ArchiveWeb.page is published under AGPL-3.0. Browsertrix can be self-hosted, and professional support is sold for self-hosted deployments. |
| Cost and access: Free to use at archive.org, with the collections searchable through the Wayback Machine. | Cost and access: Academic institutions and courts can register for free and provide accounts to their users. Other users take a paid subscription or buy batches of links. A subscription limits only new links created each month, not access to existing ones. | Cost and access: ArchiveWeb.page is free. Browsertrix is a paid subscription (Starter after a 7-day trial, Standard and Plus), with custom quotes for Pro and Enterprise. |