Boxes.py Box Generator compared with Autodesk Fusion add-ins (typical) and Inkscape| Boxes.py Box Generator | Autodesk Fusion add-ins (typical) | Inkscape |
|---|
| Approach: It offers finished parametrized generators and a Python API to write new ones. Categories include boxes, boxes with flex, trays and drawer inserts, shelves, wall-mounted items and hole patterns. | Approach: The add-ins checked (Box Joint and TabGen) work on a 3D model in Autodesk Fusion. Box Joint adds a finger joint as an editable timeline feature, and TabGen cuts tabs or notches into a selected face. They do not generate whole boxes. | Approach: It is an SVG-based vector graphics editor. The Boxes.py documentation describes Boxes.py as an Inkscape plug-in. |
| Joints and features: Finger and flat dovetail joints, flex cuts, and holes and slots for screws, hinges, gears and pulleys are available. | Joints and features: Box Joint creates CNC-friendly finger joints that can be cut flat from one side on a 3-axis machine, with axial and lateral clearance parameters. TabGen offers automatic or constant finger width, margins and kerf adjustment. | |
| Output formats: It generates SVG and can produce PostScript. DXF, PLT (HPGL) and G-code are possible with pstoedit as an external helper. | Output formats: The result is a 3D body in Fusion. A 2D DXF for cutting is exported afterwards from a sketch or a drawing. | Output formats: SVG is the working format, and SVG to PNG export is available. |
| Openness and maintenance: It is free software under GPL version 3 or later and is written in Python 3. The sources are on GitHub. | Openness and maintenance: Box Joint is listed as free with support through GitHub. TabGen is described as very alpha, and its author says development stopped in favor of a newer project called Silvanus. | Openness and maintenance: It is open source under the GNU GPL. |
| Access and requirements: A public gallery hosted by Hackerspace Bamberg offers the generators in the browser in several languages. | Access and requirements: Autodesk Fusion is required, which is a paid subscription with a free trial. Box Joint lists Windows and macOS install paths. | |