Maison » Repeatability vs. Reproducibility

Repeatability vs. Reproducibility

1960

Repeatability assesses precision under identical conditions, while reproducibility assesses precision when one or more conditions change, such as the operator, instrument, or location. Reproducibility variance is always greater than or equal to repeatability variance. This distinction is crucial for understanding measurement variability, especially in inter-laboratory comparisons where conditions are inherently different.

The distinction between repeatability and reproducibility is fundamental to Measurement Systems Analysis (MSA) and is formally defined in standards like ISO 5725. Repeatability represents the best-case precision of a measurement system, capturing only the random error inherent in the process under controlled conditions. Reproducibility, on the other hand, introduces systematic and random errors arising from changes in the measurement environment. These changes can include different operators, different setups of the same instrument type, different laboratories, and measurements taken over longer time periods.

The relationship between them is often expressed through variance components. The total variance observed under reproducibility conditions ([latex]s_R^2[/latex]) can be modeled as the sum of the repeatability variance ([latex]s_r^2[/latex]) and the variance between the changing conditions, such as the between-laboratory variance ([latex]s_L^2[/latex]): [latex]s_R^2 = s_r^2 + s_L^2[/latex]. This model highlights that reproducibility will always be worse than or equal to repeatability (i.e., [latex]s_R \ge s_r[/latex]). A méthode with good repeatability but poor reproducibility is not robust and its results are highly dependent on the specific context, making it unsuitable for standardization. Gage R&R studies are designed specifically to quantify these two components of variation to determine if a measurement system is adequate for its intended purpose, such as controlling a fabrication processus.

UNESCO Nomenclature: 2209
– Measurement and instrumentation

Type

Abstract System

Disruption

Foundational

Utilisation

Widespread Use

Precursors

  • The concept of experimental design and variance partitioning by Ronald Fisher
  • The increasing need for standardized testing methods to support global trade and regulation
  • The development of statistical quality control by Shewhart and Deming
  • The establishment of proficiency testing schemes by regulatory and accreditation bodies

Applications

  • inter-laboratory proficiency testing
  • standardization of test methods across different industries
  • evaluating the robustness of a measurement procedure
  • collaborative studies for establishing standard reference materials
  • Gage R&R studies in manufacturing

Brevets :

QUE

Potential Innovations Ideas

!niveaux !!! Adhésion obligatoire

Vous devez être membre de l'association pour accéder à ce contenu.

S’inscrire maintenant

Vous êtes déjà membre ? Connectez-vous ici
Related to: repeatability, reproducibility, precision, Gage R&R, inter-laboratory study, measurement systems analysis, variance components, metrology

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

DISPONIBLE POUR DE NOUVEAUX DÉFIS
Ingénieur mécanique, chef de projet ou de R&D
Développement de produits efficace

Disponible pour un nouveau défi dans un court délai.
Contactez-moi sur LinkedIn
Intégration électronique métal-plastique, Conception à coût réduit, BPF, Ergonomie, Appareils et consommables de volume moyen à élevé, Secteurs réglementés, CE et FDA, CAO, Solidworks, Lean Sigma Black Belt, ISO 13485 médical

Nous recherchons un nouveau sponsor

 

Votre entreprise ou institution est dans le domaine de la technique, de la science ou de la recherche ?
> envoyez-nous un message <

Recevez tous les nouveaux articles
Gratuit, pas de spam, email non distribué ni revendu

ou vous pouvez obtenir votre adhésion complète - gratuitement - pour accéder à tout le contenu restreint >ici<

Historical Context

(if date is unknown or not relevant, e.g. "fluid mechanics", a rounded estimation of its notable emergence is provided)

Related Invention, Innovation & Technical Principles

Retour en haut

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi