بيت » Verification vs. Validation

Verification vs. Validation

1980
  • Barry Boehm

Verification and validation (V&V) are distinct processes. Verification ensures a product meets its specified requirements (“Are you building it right?”). Validation ensures the product meets the user’s actual needs and intended use (“Are you building the right thing?”). They are complementary activities within quality management, often performed sequentially or in parallel to ensure both correctness and usefulness.

The distinction between verification and validation is fundamental to quality assurance in any complex engineering discipline, particularly software and systems engineering. Verification is an internal quality process focused on compliance with specifications. It involves activities like reviews, inspections, and walkthroughs of design documents, code, and requirements. The goal is to find defects early in the development lifecycle. For example, a code review verifies that the software adheres to coding standards and correctly implements a specific algorithm as described in a design document.

Validation, on the other hand, is an external quality process focused on fitness for purpose. It assesses whether the final product is effective in the operational environment for which it was intended. This typically involves testing the product with actual users or in a simulated real-world environment. For instance, user acceptance testing (UAT) is a validation activity where end-users test the software to see if it helps them perform their tasks efficiently and effectively. A system can be perfectly verified—meaning it has no bugs and meets all documented specifications—but still fail validation if those specifications were flawed or did not accurately capture the user’s true needs.

Barry Boehm’s work emphasized that these two activities answer different questions and are crucial for delivering a successful product. Neglecting verification leads to a buggy, unreliable product, while neglecting validation leads to a product that, while technically sound, is ultimately useless to its intended audience. The two processes work in tandem to ensure both correctness and usefulness.

UNESCO Nomenclature: 1203
– Computer Science

النوع

Abstract System

Disruption

Substantial

الاستخدام

Widespread Use

Precursors

  • early concepts of quality control in manufacturing
  • formal logic and proof theory
  • structured programming principles
  • early software testing methodologies

التطبيقات

  • agile software development methodologies
  • systems engineering lifecycle models (e.g., v-model)
  • pharmaceutical drug development protocols
  • aerospace systems certification (e.g., DO-178C)
  • medical device approval processes (e.g., FDA regulations)

براءات الاختراع:

NA

Potential Innovations Ideas

!!مستويات !!! العضوية مطلوبة

يجب أن تكون عضوًا !!! مستويات!!! للوصول إلى هذا المحتوى.

انضم الآن

هل أنت عضو بالفعل؟ سجّل الدخول هنا
Related to: verification, validation, quality assurance, software engineering, systems engineering, requirements, specification, testing

اترك تعليقاً

لن يتم نشر عنوان بريدك الإلكتروني. الحقول الإلزامية مشار إليها بـ *

متاح للتحديات الجديدة
مهندس ميكانيكي، مدير مشروع أو بحث وتطوير
تطوير المنتج الفعال

متاح لتحدي جديد في غضون مهلة قصيرة.
تواصل معي على LinkedIn
تكامل الإلكترونيات المعدنية والبلاستيكية، التصميم حسب التكلفة، ممارسات التصنيع الجيدة (GMP)، بيئة العمل، الأجهزة والمواد الاستهلاكية متوسطة إلى عالية الحجم، الصناعات الخاضعة للتنظيم، شهادات CE وFDA، التصميم بمساعدة الحاسوب (CAD)، Solidworks، الحزام الأسود Lean Sigma، شهادة ISO 13485 الطبية

نحن نبحث عن راعي جديد

 

هل شركتك أو مؤسستك متخصصة في التقنية أو العلوم أو الأبحاث؟
> أرسل لنا رسالة <

احصل على جميع المقالات الجديدة
مجاني، لا يوجد بريد عشوائي، ولا يتم توزيع البريد الإلكتروني ولا إعادة بيعه

أو يمكنك الحصول على عضويتك الكاملة -مجانًا- للوصول إلى جميع المحتويات المحظورة >هنا<

Historical Context

(if date is unknown or not relevant, e.g. "fluid mechanics", a rounded estimation of its notable emergence is provided)

Related Invention, Innovation & Technical Principles

Scroll to Top

قد يعجبك أيضاً